Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sectionalism Archive's avatar

Reasons Castizo futurism is dumb:

1) Hispanics are probably *not* assimilating into conservatism. The Hispanics becoming republicans are first generation immigrants, funnily enough, while later gens are more liberal even if you correct for age.

2) Castizos for the most part will either identify as Hispanic or only very loosely and meaninglessly identify as White. A large problem already for White Identity is the perception that someone’s “not white, but Irish” or “descended from [european] immigrants” so they think they might as well not identify with anything. Castizos would be this x10 and would mix with other races at even higher rates. There isn’t really a way to convince the margins of whiteness to identify more with their whiteness than the actual white people, and on top of that expect to get some sort of elite slice of said margin. A lot of race realist arguments might no longer work if whiteness was phased out this much

3) Castizos aren’t White, genetically, and we should seek racial categories with some real world genetic consistency.

Plox read my substack where I talk both about this and the hapa question more in-depth.

https://substack.com/home/post/p-146293989

Expand full comment
True European's avatar

The Irish not being white trope until post ww2 is regularly brought up by pro non white immigration advocates. The reality is that all of the exclusionary attitude towards the Irish were because they were Roman Catholic AND English speaking thus having a potential to threaten the WASP cohorts identity.The Republican party kept them out no matter how wealthy they got (Kennedy Sr was prevented from joining)but they did get revenge by acting almost like a 'glue 'holding the party together.

Expand full comment
71 more comments...

No posts