People would have to be pretty unworldly not to notice that the predominantly liberal Jews of North America are utterly unlike the Jews of Israel. The performative, fairly shallow, Zionism of the former reflects ethnosectarian and political conditions specific to the US and Canada, while the Zionism of the latter is imbued with harsher, more vigorous, qualities generated by war and by the long history of the
Jews of the Islamic world. Moreover, American Zionism is essentially about managing relationships between the regime and organised Jewry rather than anything to do with Israel.
The present situation is dynamic. In the West the vast majority of Jews will share the fate of whites (replacement immigration and deprioritisation under the pretense of civil rights) and their views will reflect that. Pragmatists will work with this, while misfits and ideologues clutch their pearls and squeal about hypocrisy.
The geopolitics of Zionism are also changing. The US/Israel alliance began in the late 60s (safter the conclusion of the 6 Day War) because the US sought to bring the Israelis into the US camp. The future of the relationship is likely to depend upon the fate of the petrodollar and the success (or failure) of Eurasian economic integration.
Whites face a future involving networked tribalism on a planetary scale, speciation, ethnogenesis and increasing rivalry from other races. I'd expect that some white sub-groups will find the experience of Diaspora Jews useful, while others will feel the same way about Israel.
Finally, Israel itself is a blend of distinct ethno-cultural strands (some undeniably white, others not) united (to a degree) by a shared religion and nationality. We may well see something similar develop in the West with white tribes co-existing with white-adjacent and white-compatible fellow minorities. I'd argue that we need a pragmatic and realistic assessment of all of this, rather than an emotional/moralistic one.
I don’t think Hispanic immigration to America is a good analogy for the so called Palestinian right of return. It’s more analogous to a migration of a huge number of Africans, 3/4 of whom would support a 10/7 style attack on white people.
Israel also has affirmative action for Arabs in the educational system, for whatever it’s worth.
If "liberal zionists" are hypocritices because their double standard about wokism so even the anti-woke-anti-zionist crowd is since they get annoyed by da jooz, but they say nothing about all the other minorities getting advantage of wokism as well.
Moreover, all this "Israel is losing popularity among the American public so things are going to change AHAHAHHAHA get over with that kike" sound extremely naive and guilible.
Second, because all the dissonant rightoid rebellion against "jooz power" is just a pathetc giant LARPING closed in a echo chamber wich the only function is to keep the sperg vote in line in order to get Trump elected. Same film watched in 2016, and guess what? After Trump was elected Zionist power was never so powerful like during his administration, and the only minion who believed in the fucking anti-kikes meme got sentenced to death with Trump assent. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/jury-recommends-sentence-death-pennsylvania-man-convicted-tree-life-synagogue-shooting
Just a matter of time and if the organge guy will be re-elected you will see the Star of David proudly waving together with the Dixie one again. And all those minions like Candace Owens, Jackson Hinkle, Lucas Gage will all get thrown in a trash bin like poor Dickie Spencer after Charlottesville.
Some streamlining may benefit this piece as it is a bit contorted and it's difficult to understand what's the point being conveyed.
If it's that Israelis can be seen as a largely different group of interest than New York Jews, and hence opposing the former due to animosity against the latter totally misses the mark, then duh, we knew beforehand that New York Jews see their Israeli cousins as a bunch of yokels.
Still, as is hinted at in the first part of the essay, leftist and third-worldist antiWhite stances have been basically brewed by Jews, those located in America and in the wider West, throughout the post-War era. There would have been no contemporary woke, and no 60s counter-culture for that matter, without Jews.
The link between Jew diasporas and Israel which you omit to mention is that New York Jews see Israel as a last resort for protection in case things head south again for them in Gentile nations. A sort of psychological redoubt they feel they have the need to defend at all costs.
So I don't think the New York Jewish pro-Palestinian stances that you make us aware of inside your essay are anything but the usual tripe of rich people signaling support for retarded causes just to show off their own privilege of being shielded from any of the ill-fated consequences naturally stemming from those imbecilic causes (this is archetypal behaviour of the high classes, e.g. see https://web.archive.org/web/20220609022455/https://www.takimag.com/article/wholly-macaroni/). I am sure that instead, deep inside they would feel lost, exposed, vulnerable if anything were to happen to Israel.
On another note, me wonders why do you cling so much to your Jewish ancestry which you wrote represents only 1/16 of your ancestry. I mean, it's an objectively negligible proportion: yes the big lithuanian rabbi wrote the infamous book on the hot topic, but still given the crap these people has been heaping upon the rest of the White men since hey have existed as a diaspora, I wouldn't identify so keenly with that part of my heritage if I were you.
A lot of dissidents are so alienated from Western institutions that they almost cease to be Westerners.</blockquote>
me: There is no "west" that serves the interests of White gentiles anymore. There are only European and Anglosphere nations that are doing "What's best for the jews", and that, according to you jews, is replacing White gentiles with infinity non White migrants. What pro White advocate would ever support any one of these zog infested ruling classes/nations? Why be loyal to a society that wants your people replaced and eliminated? Don't be dumb, jew. Any White gentile that supports or fights for any "western nation" is a moron. Until the anti White jewish ruling class and their shabbos goy puppets are gone....and until pro White advocates rule the nations of Europe and the Anglosphere...there is no "west" worth fighting for.
<blockquote>There are legit criticisms of Israel, including humanitarian, but the problem with the dissident right adopting anti-Zionism, is that it operates under an anti-nationalist framework.</blockquote>
me: Wrong jew. You can be a pro White advocate that wants ethnostates for Europe and the Anglosphere, and also supports ethnostates for other peoples (nigerians, congolese, japanese, mexicans, peruvians, koreans, etc)....but still be against cowardly bullies carpet bombing tens of thousands of unarmed and innocent women and children. I literally know of no single White nationalist that would support murdering tens of thousands of non White innocent civilians the way you jews are doing to the Palestinians today. Supporting identity politics for all peoples, and being opposed to blowing civilians up and driving over their bodies with tractors are only mutually exclusive things in the mind of a hasbara jew like you trying to fool non jews.
<blockquote>Under the surface of this resentment, the dissident right has an element of admiration for Israel’s will to survive and to be ruthless to secure its long term demographic future, in contrast with European nations that pander to foreigners who show contempt in turn.
</blockquote>
me: LOL. No jew. Our resentment is that you jews demand us White gentiles destroy our demographic future because it's "good for the jews", yet you jews demand the complete opposite for israel (demographic security for jews). We don't admire you, as you said in the beginning, we think you are hypocritical, backstabbing rats that should never have been permitted to live among us, because you will always push a "what's good for the jews" agenda, regardless of how it harms us and our children. Don't pat yourself on the back too soon there shlomo.
<blockquote>Calling out the hypocrisy of pro-Israel Jewish organizations and individuals is fine without going full Jew obsessed 14/88 nutjob</blockquote>
me: LOL. The arrogant jew telling the lowly goyim what they can/cannot do....what they can/cannot think. Listen you arrogant jerk, you are not chosen. Nobody chose you above all the other people on earth. The rabbis made up the whole ethnocult thing. We will do what we want, whether or not you fragile jews have a problem with it or not.
In a nutshell, your joke of an essay here is truly repulsive, and a blatant attempt to serve jewish interests. Don't even try to pretend you or your people are friends of White gentiles or pro White advocates. You aren't. You are a slimy, backstabbing, subversive, cowardly, dishonest JEW that has the morality of a viper, and the honor of a cockroach. On the whole, you are truly a disgusting tribe, devoid of integrity or truth. A wise man once said "I hate that the 99% of jews make the 1% look bad". In my experience, those numbers are likely accurate.
As a group, you jews never care about consistency or fairness. You just care about what's "good for the jews". Your twisted, supremacist ethnocult "religion" teaches you that non jews MUST serve your interests, and they too must do what's "good for the jews". No need for consistency or fairness....all that matters is what's "good for the jews".
The whole first two thirds of your essay explains how jews are completely hypocritical....on immigration...on identity politics....on nationalism....on censorship....
Yet, at the very end, you demand that White gentiles be consistent? Really? Why? Why should non jews be consistent if jews aren't? Isn't this just one more jewish hypocrisy shlomo?
If jews think it's "good for the jews" if White gentile interests are crushed, why can't White gentiles similarly think it's "good for White gentiles" if jewish interests are crushed? Turnabout is fair play.
<blockquote>Sweden and Ireland, which both have hardly any Jews, have establishments that are pro-Palestinian while pursuing suicidal policies for their national demographic interests</blockquote>
me: You are either ignorant, jew, or a lying jew, or possibly both.
In addition, the way jewish ngos work now is that they go in at the EU level in brussels and demand open borders/White genocide for member states. See the example of both Hungary and Poland, where the shabbos goys of the EU are demanding those states take in non White migrants or else be severely punished. For centuries jews have been subverting via finding the power levers and using those to push their agendas. The EU of today is no different than jews buying kings/royalty in centuries past.
<blockquote>Humza Yousaf, has strong ties to the Palestinian cause and is viciously anti-White.</blockquote>
me: yeah, and if any White gentiles in Scotland or elsewhere dare to speak the truth about this anti White rat, jews will demand that those people be punished under draconian speech laws. If jews and jewish ngos weren't operating in the UK, exactly how long do you think this brown rat would hold up to scrutiny if free expression and free speech were allowed? If jewish censors didn't dominate the speech codes landscape in the UK, this brown rat never would have become pm.
<blockquote>From a Jewish perspective, being told you are a colonizer in the Middle East but also that you don’t fully belong in the West is going to create some neurosis. Ashkenazi Jews, at least</blockquote>
me: Yes, you jews are psychopaths due to your extremist religion and the extremist culture it has created. In addition, DNA evidence shows that the male line of ashkenazis is middle eastern, but <b>the female line of ashkenazis is White gentile European</b>. This means that jews are half European White gentile......YET virtually every ashkenutty jew I have ever met has been an anti White pos that would relish if all Europeans and their descendants were exterminated. Weird huh? Hating half of your genome and wanting is wiped out forever. Certainly that WOULD create some kind of twisted neurosis!!! Imagine being half black and half east asian and wanting all east asians to be wiped out forever. Certainly that would make for one confused individual. <b> One last thing. Since the maternal line of ashkenazis is White gentile European, that means, according to traditional jewish custom, ashkenazis aren't even "real jews" as the female line isn't semitic/jewish/middle eastern.</b> So yes, ashkenutties have multiple reasons to be confused, disturbed, and psychotic. I agree.
<blockquote>The perverse nature of left-wing anti-Zionism is that Whites are somehow responsible for Palestinian “genocide,” </blockquote>
me: Yes, because left wingnut jews can never blame JEWS for jewish wrongdoing because they don't hate jews. But left wing jews HATE White gentiles, so instead of blaming jews for the mass murder of Palestinian civilians, they blame White people for it. Just more jewish anti White bs. Same old story. I saw similar goy-blaming multiple times when the jews glenn greenwald and max blumenthal were on jimmy dore's show. Instead of blaming JEWish AIPAC, and jewish israel firsters for the US middle east policy, they put all the blame on the MIC. While the MIC is undoubtedly involved in warmongering and war profiteering, AIPAC heavily influences WHO the US sees as "threats" and WHO it treats as pariahs. For greenwald and blumenthal to downplay AIPAC, and the JEW neocons and their involvement is preposterous and completely immoral and dishonest.
<blockquote>and Jews being perceived as White, changing demographics with a non-White America favoring the Palestinians</blockquote>
me: Yet still, YOU JEWS will endlessly push for every White country on earth to turn more brown. You jews have been so propagandized by your rabbis and elites that White people are the "scariest people on earth" that you simply can not, or will not stop pushing your White genocide and anti White agendas. That is why ALL you jews must be expelled from every western nation. The survival of the peoples of Europe depends on it. It you jews should be able to continue as a distinct ethnic group on earth, why shouldn't the Irish, Scots, Swedes, Poles, Italians, Spaniards, French, Germans, Russians, and all the others? After all, fair is fair.
<blockquote>Perhaps the age of Zionist hypocrisy will eventually be a thing of the past, and they will become just another group of rightwing ethno-nationalists, willing to join other rightwing nationalists properly on the global stage.</blockquote>
me: Nope. That will never happen. Jews hate White gentiles and want us wiped out/blended out of existence. Jews will never side with White gentile nationalists in Europe and elsewhere. I'd put lots and lots of money on that bet. They could pay lip service to it....but it would just be a ruse, they will never put their full force behind it the way they put their full force behind jewish interests. Jews LOVE genocide. Their sick, extremist religion completely endorses it. You have heard of the Amaleks, haven't you, jew? According to the torah, the jewish sky ghost demanded the jews exterminate (genocide) every last man, woman and child of the Amaleks for daring to go against the jews.
<blockquote>1 Samuel 15:3 Now go and attack the Amalekites and devote to destruction all that belongs to them. Do not spare them, but put to death men and women, children and infants, oxen and sheep, camels and donkeys.'"</blockquote>
You jews have labelled countless peoples you have come into contact with as "amaleks"....or deserving of complete genocide. The fact that you jews have been whining for almost 100 years for allegedly 33% of the jews supposedly being "victims" of "genocide" is sooooo rich considering you jews believe genocide is a "good thing" as long as it serves jewish interests or gets jews "revenge". Countless jews today clearly believe all White gentiles are "Amaleks" and deserving of being wiped out because of things that a minority of White gentiles allegedly did 100, 200, or even 500 years ago. A fine example of a typical jew:
<blockquote>Baruch Efrati, a yeshiva head and community rabbi in the West Bank settlement. He said,
Jews should rejoice at the fact that Christian Europe is losing its identity as a punishment for what it did to us for the hundreds of years we were in exile there. We will never forgive Europe s Christians for slaughtering millions of our children, women and elderly not just in the recent Holocaust, but throughout the generations, in a consistent manner which characterizes all factions of hypocritical Christianity </blockquote>
<blockquote>with Musk agreeing to crack down on pro-Palestinian activism while going softer on pro-White type stuff</blockquote>
me: BS. You can't be a pro White advocate without addressing the jq. Jews are the ones at the forefront of demanding that White gentile identity politics be crushed. Kevin MacDonald, Lucas Gage, me, and countless others have been temporarily banned or permabanned by shabbos musk for daring to be pro White and for discussing jewish involvement in the replacement immigration and anti White agenda in the west.
<blockquote>Ideally, Trump should have pressured Israel to rein in the anti-Whiteness amongst diaspora organizations.</blockquote>
me: Too little, too late jew. Until jews start heavy action on repatriation of the tens of millions of non White migrants in Europe and the Anglosphere back to their homelands....until jews start boosting identity politics for White gentiles in Europe and the Anglosphere (like they do for all other groups).....until jews realize that they cannot live among non jews without pushing their supremacist ethnocult belief that the goyim MUST serve jewish interests, thus being together will never work out, so all jews should move to israel permanently.....until all that happens, it is way too little, way too late jew. Your people have done too much damage for there to be a redemption. Unless you can undo all the harm you have done....it won't be enough.
<blockquote>While a lot of White identitarians are both Islamophobic and antisemitic, the pro-Palestinian side is aligned with Islamists and Third Worldism, which includes opposition to Whiteness</blockquote>
me: Yes, because you jews dominate hollywood and the msm. So gullible non Whites buy the jewish anti White worldview. Some non Whites have slipped through the cracks and began to see the light...Kanye West, Tommy Sotomayor, Rick Sanchez, Michael Jackson, Louis Farrakhan, and others. Trust me jew, if pro White advocates like me dominated the msm and hollywood, non Whites wouldn't be blaming Whitey for all the world's problems....they would be blaming people like (((larry fink))), (((les wexner))), (((sergey brin))), (((larry page))), the (((adl))), (((aipac))), (((epstein/mossad))), (((soros))), and (((countless others))). The White gentiles and others that get the blame would be the shabbos goy traitors that have prostituted themselves for shekels.
<blockquote>For the most part, I advocate for neutrality, just letting the two political sides go at it while keeping the moral high ground on non-intervention.</blockquote>
me: Only brain dead White gentiles would take guidance from a tribally minded jew like you. YOU are out to serve JEWISH interests, not White gentile interests, you subversive, backstabbing filth.
<blockquote>Despite being pro-Israel, the mainstream Right is now just discovering this double standard narrative. (ie, jewish double standards about identity politics, immigration, nationalism, etc)</blockquote>
me: You sound scared, JEW. Why are you so terrified of non jews pointing out jews and their anti White double standards? Don't you think people should know the truth?
<blockquote>Ben Shapiro has been gatekeeping other conservatives</blockquote>
me: Exactly...he is just another hypocritical jew who pushes identity politics for jews, but doesn't want White gentiles to engage in identity politics.
<blockquote>This critique goes beyond Jewish liberals in the diaspora, with a lot of Alt-Right types viewing Israel as a mortal enemy of those of White European descent</blockquote>
me: Jews are the mortal enemies of White gentiles everywhere....whether they are jews in the diaspora, or jews in israel makes no difference. A jew is a jew. All jews without exception should be expelled from the west, permanently. Jews now have their own country...they should all go there, and leave all gentiles of the world alone instead of endlessly whining about how everyone hates them for no reason. Jews subvert wherever they go, pushing their hosts to serve jewish interests regardless of how those interests conflict with the interests of their hosts. This has and will always be the problem with jews living among non jews. That is why they should only live among other jews in israel. Their ethnocult extremist religion inculcates fear of the other, hatred of the other, and the demand that the other serve jews and their interests. It is a recipe for conflict.
<blockquote>If someone staunchly supports Israeli nationalism but is okay with White people being dispossessed in the West, it is understandable that they will get accused of being anti-Western
</blockquote>
me: So, JEW, you clearly understand why we White gentiles are angry. Why not just change your jewish anti White behavior, rather than pushing your hasbara jewish bs?
<blockquote>Not to mention that most of the White gentile elite are on board with policies, like mass immigration, and are quick to throw ordinary Whites under the bus.</blockquote>
me: Yeah, maybe because you jews dominate the msm, and the judenpresse and jewish ngos will literally destroy anyone that gets out of line with the jewish White genocide and jewish anti White agenda. Just look at what jewish terrorists did to kanye west, whoopie goldberg, rick sanchez, the president of harvard, and president of penn when they dared to get out of line. In addition, jews have been getting dirt on White gentiles for a long time in order to get them in line with the jewish anti White agenda. You know, the way epstein/mossad did to countless people! Jews love to terrorize non jews....and then they whine like little girls when non jews dare to fight back. It's your sick ethnocult that demands jews make non jews serve jewish interests. It's your sick ethnocult that demands jews terrorize non jews:
What the Alt-Right gets wrong is that Jewish people who supported BLM generally don’t care for Netanyahu, and </blockquote>
me: What YOU get wrong jew, is that we don't care. Jews, whether left wing, or right wing are against White gentiles pushing for our interests in our nations. Thus, jews are the enemies of White gentiles. Until YOU jews support White identity politics the way you support jewish/hispanic/black, etc identity politics in the west, all we will consider you is enemies. Capisce, shlomo?
<blockquote>The Alt-Right will use anti-racist activist, Tim Wise</blockquote>
me: jew tim wise isn't an "anti racist activist", he is just another jewish anti White scumball that grifts off of gullible non Whites and brain-dead White gentile lefttards. He's a complete hypocrite on race.
<blockquote>While George Soros is often given as an example of a Jewish oligarch who funds the Great Replacement, it is important to point out that Soros also funds anti-Israel causes.</blockquote>
me: So? When has soros funded open borders for israel? When has soros funded groups trying to prevent identity politics for jews in israel and abroad? When has soros tried to destroy the jewish ADL and other jewish ngos that are absolutely against quote-unquote "open societies" and free speech? I'll help you here. The answer is never!
Palestine and Palestinians have nothing to do with America First. Neither does Israel. If someone invokes Israel and its concerns they are trying to link Zionism with America First. George Washington said, "Anyone who believes two nations can have identical interests is delusional". Israel is our greatest liability, and apparently we will let it plummet us to the bottom of the sea with Bibi and Trump "in control".
Thought provoking article - thank you Robert. When you use the enemy's verbiage, you legitimize their ideology. Say antiwhite. That's what they are, whether they call themselves "woke" or "anti-racist". What you called hypocrisy is just their consistent antiwhiteism, no?
The civilised world is becoming increasingly multicultural. Ethnonationalism will have no place in 2100, and Israel in its current form will have to accept multiculturalism and pluralism or become a Rightoid pariah state. No doubt Israel supporters will shift rightward as Israel goes in a similar direction, allowing more steam to be released by tactfully talking about "anti-whiteness" to get the Western rubes on board. In the long term, it's not going to work; the direction Israel is going in is towards religious fundamentalism, blood and soil nationalism, and ethnic cleansing. This can provide Western Rightoids a way to live vicariously through Israel as it commits these crimes—since they can't commit these actions against Muslims in the West—but it will also make them look like ghouls.
People would have to be pretty unworldly not to notice that the predominantly liberal Jews of North America are utterly unlike the Jews of Israel. The performative, fairly shallow, Zionism of the former reflects ethnosectarian and political conditions specific to the US and Canada, while the Zionism of the latter is imbued with harsher, more vigorous, qualities generated by war and by the long history of the
Jews of the Islamic world. Moreover, American Zionism is essentially about managing relationships between the regime and organised Jewry rather than anything to do with Israel.
The present situation is dynamic. In the West the vast majority of Jews will share the fate of whites (replacement immigration and deprioritisation under the pretense of civil rights) and their views will reflect that. Pragmatists will work with this, while misfits and ideologues clutch their pearls and squeal about hypocrisy.
The geopolitics of Zionism are also changing. The US/Israel alliance began in the late 60s (safter the conclusion of the 6 Day War) because the US sought to bring the Israelis into the US camp. The future of the relationship is likely to depend upon the fate of the petrodollar and the success (or failure) of Eurasian economic integration.
Whites face a future involving networked tribalism on a planetary scale, speciation, ethnogenesis and increasing rivalry from other races. I'd expect that some white sub-groups will find the experience of Diaspora Jews useful, while others will feel the same way about Israel.
Finally, Israel itself is a blend of distinct ethno-cultural strands (some undeniably white, others not) united (to a degree) by a shared religion and nationality. We may well see something similar develop in the West with white tribes co-existing with white-adjacent and white-compatible fellow minorities. I'd argue that we need a pragmatic and realistic assessment of all of this, rather than an emotional/moralistic one.
I don’t think Hispanic immigration to America is a good analogy for the so called Palestinian right of return. It’s more analogous to a migration of a huge number of Africans, 3/4 of whom would support a 10/7 style attack on white people.
Israel also has affirmative action for Arabs in the educational system, for whatever it’s worth.
If "liberal zionists" are hypocritices because their double standard about wokism so even the anti-woke-anti-zionist crowd is since they get annoyed by da jooz, but they say nothing about all the other minorities getting advantage of wokism as well.
Moreover, all this "Israel is losing popularity among the American public so things are going to change AHAHAHHAHA get over with that kike" sound extremely naive and guilible.
First, because it's untrue the public is against Israel: https://www.pewresearch.org/2024/03/21/majority-in-u-s-say-israel-has-valid-reasons-for-fighting-fewer-say-the-same-about-hamas/
Second, because all the dissonant rightoid rebellion against "jooz power" is just a pathetc giant LARPING closed in a echo chamber wich the only function is to keep the sperg vote in line in order to get Trump elected. Same film watched in 2016, and guess what? After Trump was elected Zionist power was never so powerful like during his administration, and the only minion who believed in the fucking anti-kikes meme got sentenced to death with Trump assent. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/jury-recommends-sentence-death-pennsylvania-man-convicted-tree-life-synagogue-shooting
Just a matter of time and if the organge guy will be re-elected you will see the Star of David proudly waving together with the Dixie one again. And all those minions like Candace Owens, Jackson Hinkle, Lucas Gage will all get thrown in a trash bin like poor Dickie Spencer after Charlottesville.
Some streamlining may benefit this piece as it is a bit contorted and it's difficult to understand what's the point being conveyed.
If it's that Israelis can be seen as a largely different group of interest than New York Jews, and hence opposing the former due to animosity against the latter totally misses the mark, then duh, we knew beforehand that New York Jews see their Israeli cousins as a bunch of yokels.
Still, as is hinted at in the first part of the essay, leftist and third-worldist antiWhite stances have been basically brewed by Jews, those located in America and in the wider West, throughout the post-War era. There would have been no contemporary woke, and no 60s counter-culture for that matter, without Jews.
The link between Jew diasporas and Israel which you omit to mention is that New York Jews see Israel as a last resort for protection in case things head south again for them in Gentile nations. A sort of psychological redoubt they feel they have the need to defend at all costs.
So I don't think the New York Jewish pro-Palestinian stances that you make us aware of inside your essay are anything but the usual tripe of rich people signaling support for retarded causes just to show off their own privilege of being shielded from any of the ill-fated consequences naturally stemming from those imbecilic causes (this is archetypal behaviour of the high classes, e.g. see https://web.archive.org/web/20220609022455/https://www.takimag.com/article/wholly-macaroni/). I am sure that instead, deep inside they would feel lost, exposed, vulnerable if anything were to happen to Israel.
On another note, me wonders why do you cling so much to your Jewish ancestry which you wrote represents only 1/16 of your ancestry. I mean, it's an objectively negligible proportion: yes the big lithuanian rabbi wrote the infamous book on the hot topic, but still given the crap these people has been heaping upon the rest of the White men since hey have existed as a diaspora, I wouldn't identify so keenly with that part of my heritage if I were you.
part 3
<blockquote>
A lot of dissidents are so alienated from Western institutions that they almost cease to be Westerners.</blockquote>
me: There is no "west" that serves the interests of White gentiles anymore. There are only European and Anglosphere nations that are doing "What's best for the jews", and that, according to you jews, is replacing White gentiles with infinity non White migrants. What pro White advocate would ever support any one of these zog infested ruling classes/nations? Why be loyal to a society that wants your people replaced and eliminated? Don't be dumb, jew. Any White gentile that supports or fights for any "western nation" is a moron. Until the anti White jewish ruling class and their shabbos goy puppets are gone....and until pro White advocates rule the nations of Europe and the Anglosphere...there is no "west" worth fighting for.
<blockquote>There are legit criticisms of Israel, including humanitarian, but the problem with the dissident right adopting anti-Zionism, is that it operates under an anti-nationalist framework.</blockquote>
me: Wrong jew. You can be a pro White advocate that wants ethnostates for Europe and the Anglosphere, and also supports ethnostates for other peoples (nigerians, congolese, japanese, mexicans, peruvians, koreans, etc)....but still be against cowardly bullies carpet bombing tens of thousands of unarmed and innocent women and children. I literally know of no single White nationalist that would support murdering tens of thousands of non White innocent civilians the way you jews are doing to the Palestinians today. Supporting identity politics for all peoples, and being opposed to blowing civilians up and driving over their bodies with tractors are only mutually exclusive things in the mind of a hasbara jew like you trying to fool non jews.
<blockquote>Under the surface of this resentment, the dissident right has an element of admiration for Israel’s will to survive and to be ruthless to secure its long term demographic future, in contrast with European nations that pander to foreigners who show contempt in turn.
</blockquote>
me: LOL. No jew. Our resentment is that you jews demand us White gentiles destroy our demographic future because it's "good for the jews", yet you jews demand the complete opposite for israel (demographic security for jews). We don't admire you, as you said in the beginning, we think you are hypocritical, backstabbing rats that should never have been permitted to live among us, because you will always push a "what's good for the jews" agenda, regardless of how it harms us and our children. Don't pat yourself on the back too soon there shlomo.
<blockquote>Calling out the hypocrisy of pro-Israel Jewish organizations and individuals is fine without going full Jew obsessed 14/88 nutjob</blockquote>
me: LOL. The arrogant jew telling the lowly goyim what they can/cannot do....what they can/cannot think. Listen you arrogant jerk, you are not chosen. Nobody chose you above all the other people on earth. The rabbis made up the whole ethnocult thing. We will do what we want, whether or not you fragile jews have a problem with it or not.
In a nutshell, your joke of an essay here is truly repulsive, and a blatant attempt to serve jewish interests. Don't even try to pretend you or your people are friends of White gentiles or pro White advocates. You aren't. You are a slimy, backstabbing, subversive, cowardly, dishonest JEW that has the morality of a viper, and the honor of a cockroach. On the whole, you are truly a disgusting tribe, devoid of integrity or truth. A wise man once said "I hate that the 99% of jews make the 1% look bad". In my experience, those numbers are likely accurate.
As a group, you jews never care about consistency or fairness. You just care about what's "good for the jews". Your twisted, supremacist ethnocult "religion" teaches you that non jews MUST serve your interests, and they too must do what's "good for the jews". No need for consistency or fairness....all that matters is what's "good for the jews".
The whole first two thirds of your essay explains how jews are completely hypocritical....on immigration...on identity politics....on nationalism....on censorship....
Yet, at the very end, you demand that White gentiles be consistent? Really? Why? Why should non jews be consistent if jews aren't? Isn't this just one more jewish hypocrisy shlomo?
If jews think it's "good for the jews" if White gentile interests are crushed, why can't White gentiles similarly think it's "good for White gentiles" if jewish interests are crushed? Turnabout is fair play.
part 2
<blockquote>Sweden and Ireland, which both have hardly any Jews, have establishments that are pro-Palestinian while pursuing suicidal policies for their national demographic interests</blockquote>
me: You are either ignorant, jew, or a lying jew, or possibly both.
<b>jews in ireland pushing open borders:</b>
https://www.theoccidentalobserver.net/2019/08/30/become-other-than-white-ireland-and-radical-jewish-activism/
<b>jewish open borders pusher in sweden:</b>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G45WthPTo24&t=6s
In addition, the way jewish ngos work now is that they go in at the EU level in brussels and demand open borders/White genocide for member states. See the example of both Hungary and Poland, where the shabbos goys of the EU are demanding those states take in non White migrants or else be severely punished. For centuries jews have been subverting via finding the power levers and using those to push their agendas. The EU of today is no different than jews buying kings/royalty in centuries past.
<blockquote>Humza Yousaf, has strong ties to the Palestinian cause and is viciously anti-White.</blockquote>
me: yeah, and if any White gentiles in Scotland or elsewhere dare to speak the truth about this anti White rat, jews will demand that those people be punished under draconian speech laws. If jews and jewish ngos weren't operating in the UK, exactly how long do you think this brown rat would hold up to scrutiny if free expression and free speech were allowed? If jewish censors didn't dominate the speech codes landscape in the UK, this brown rat never would have become pm.
<blockquote>From a Jewish perspective, being told you are a colonizer in the Middle East but also that you don’t fully belong in the West is going to create some neurosis. Ashkenazi Jews, at least</blockquote>
me: Yes, you jews are psychopaths due to your extremist religion and the extremist culture it has created. In addition, DNA evidence shows that the male line of ashkenazis is middle eastern, but <b>the female line of ashkenazis is White gentile European</b>. This means that jews are half European White gentile......YET virtually every ashkenutty jew I have ever met has been an anti White pos that would relish if all Europeans and their descendants were exterminated. Weird huh? Hating half of your genome and wanting is wiped out forever. Certainly that WOULD create some kind of twisted neurosis!!! Imagine being half black and half east asian and wanting all east asians to be wiped out forever. Certainly that would make for one confused individual. <b> One last thing. Since the maternal line of ashkenazis is White gentile European, that means, according to traditional jewish custom, ashkenazis aren't even "real jews" as the female line isn't semitic/jewish/middle eastern.</b> So yes, ashkenutties have multiple reasons to be confused, disturbed, and psychotic. I agree.
<blockquote>The perverse nature of left-wing anti-Zionism is that Whites are somehow responsible for Palestinian “genocide,” </blockquote>
me: Yes, because left wingnut jews can never blame JEWS for jewish wrongdoing because they don't hate jews. But left wing jews HATE White gentiles, so instead of blaming jews for the mass murder of Palestinian civilians, they blame White people for it. Just more jewish anti White bs. Same old story. I saw similar goy-blaming multiple times when the jews glenn greenwald and max blumenthal were on jimmy dore's show. Instead of blaming JEWish AIPAC, and jewish israel firsters for the US middle east policy, they put all the blame on the MIC. While the MIC is undoubtedly involved in warmongering and war profiteering, AIPAC heavily influences WHO the US sees as "threats" and WHO it treats as pariahs. For greenwald and blumenthal to downplay AIPAC, and the JEW neocons and their involvement is preposterous and completely immoral and dishonest.
<blockquote>and Jews being perceived as White, changing demographics with a non-White America favoring the Palestinians</blockquote>
me: Yet still, YOU JEWS will endlessly push for every White country on earth to turn more brown. You jews have been so propagandized by your rabbis and elites that White people are the "scariest people on earth" that you simply can not, or will not stop pushing your White genocide and anti White agendas. That is why ALL you jews must be expelled from every western nation. The survival of the peoples of Europe depends on it. It you jews should be able to continue as a distinct ethnic group on earth, why shouldn't the Irish, Scots, Swedes, Poles, Italians, Spaniards, French, Germans, Russians, and all the others? After all, fair is fair.
<blockquote>Perhaps the age of Zionist hypocrisy will eventually be a thing of the past, and they will become just another group of rightwing ethno-nationalists, willing to join other rightwing nationalists properly on the global stage.</blockquote>
me: Nope. That will never happen. Jews hate White gentiles and want us wiped out/blended out of existence. Jews will never side with White gentile nationalists in Europe and elsewhere. I'd put lots and lots of money on that bet. They could pay lip service to it....but it would just be a ruse, they will never put their full force behind it the way they put their full force behind jewish interests. Jews LOVE genocide. Their sick, extremist religion completely endorses it. You have heard of the Amaleks, haven't you, jew? According to the torah, the jewish sky ghost demanded the jews exterminate (genocide) every last man, woman and child of the Amaleks for daring to go against the jews.
<blockquote>1 Samuel 15:3 Now go and attack the Amalekites and devote to destruction all that belongs to them. Do not spare them, but put to death men and women, children and infants, oxen and sheep, camels and donkeys.'"</blockquote>
You jews have labelled countless peoples you have come into contact with as "amaleks"....or deserving of complete genocide. The fact that you jews have been whining for almost 100 years for allegedly 33% of the jews supposedly being "victims" of "genocide" is sooooo rich considering you jews believe genocide is a "good thing" as long as it serves jewish interests or gets jews "revenge". Countless jews today clearly believe all White gentiles are "Amaleks" and deserving of being wiped out because of things that a minority of White gentiles allegedly did 100, 200, or even 500 years ago. A fine example of a typical jew:
<blockquote>Baruch Efrati, a yeshiva head and community rabbi in the West Bank settlement. He said,
Jews should rejoice at the fact that Christian Europe is losing its identity as a punishment for what it did to us for the hundreds of years we were in exile there. We will never forgive Europe s Christians for slaughtering millions of our children, women and elderly not just in the recent Holocaust, but throughout the generations, in a consistent manner which characterizes all factions of hypocritical Christianity </blockquote>
<blockquote>with Musk agreeing to crack down on pro-Palestinian activism while going softer on pro-White type stuff</blockquote>
me: BS. You can't be a pro White advocate without addressing the jq. Jews are the ones at the forefront of demanding that White gentile identity politics be crushed. Kevin MacDonald, Lucas Gage, me, and countless others have been temporarily banned or permabanned by shabbos musk for daring to be pro White and for discussing jewish involvement in the replacement immigration and anti White agenda in the west.
<blockquote>Ideally, Trump should have pressured Israel to rein in the anti-Whiteness amongst diaspora organizations.</blockquote>
me: Too little, too late jew. Until jews start heavy action on repatriation of the tens of millions of non White migrants in Europe and the Anglosphere back to their homelands....until jews start boosting identity politics for White gentiles in Europe and the Anglosphere (like they do for all other groups).....until jews realize that they cannot live among non jews without pushing their supremacist ethnocult belief that the goyim MUST serve jewish interests, thus being together will never work out, so all jews should move to israel permanently.....until all that happens, it is way too little, way too late jew. Your people have done too much damage for there to be a redemption. Unless you can undo all the harm you have done....it won't be enough.
<blockquote>While a lot of White identitarians are both Islamophobic and antisemitic, the pro-Palestinian side is aligned with Islamists and Third Worldism, which includes opposition to Whiteness</blockquote>
me: Yes, because you jews dominate hollywood and the msm. So gullible non Whites buy the jewish anti White worldview. Some non Whites have slipped through the cracks and began to see the light...Kanye West, Tommy Sotomayor, Rick Sanchez, Michael Jackson, Louis Farrakhan, and others. Trust me jew, if pro White advocates like me dominated the msm and hollywood, non Whites wouldn't be blaming Whitey for all the world's problems....they would be blaming people like (((larry fink))), (((les wexner))), (((sergey brin))), (((larry page))), the (((adl))), (((aipac))), (((epstein/mossad))), (((soros))), and (((countless others))). The White gentiles and others that get the blame would be the shabbos goy traitors that have prostituted themselves for shekels.
<blockquote>For the most part, I advocate for neutrality, just letting the two political sides go at it while keeping the moral high ground on non-intervention.</blockquote>
me: Only brain dead White gentiles would take guidance from a tribally minded jew like you. YOU are out to serve JEWISH interests, not White gentile interests, you subversive, backstabbing filth.
part 1
<blockquote>Despite being pro-Israel, the mainstream Right is now just discovering this double standard narrative. (ie, jewish double standards about identity politics, immigration, nationalism, etc)</blockquote>
me: You sound scared, JEW. Why are you so terrified of non jews pointing out jews and their anti White double standards? Don't you think people should know the truth?
<blockquote>Ben Shapiro has been gatekeeping other conservatives</blockquote>
me: Exactly...he is just another hypocritical jew who pushes identity politics for jews, but doesn't want White gentiles to engage in identity politics.
<blockquote>This critique goes beyond Jewish liberals in the diaspora, with a lot of Alt-Right types viewing Israel as a mortal enemy of those of White European descent</blockquote>
me: Jews are the mortal enemies of White gentiles everywhere....whether they are jews in the diaspora, or jews in israel makes no difference. A jew is a jew. All jews without exception should be expelled from the west, permanently. Jews now have their own country...they should all go there, and leave all gentiles of the world alone instead of endlessly whining about how everyone hates them for no reason. Jews subvert wherever they go, pushing their hosts to serve jewish interests regardless of how those interests conflict with the interests of their hosts. This has and will always be the problem with jews living among non jews. That is why they should only live among other jews in israel. Their ethnocult extremist religion inculcates fear of the other, hatred of the other, and the demand that the other serve jews and their interests. It is a recipe for conflict.
<blockquote>If someone staunchly supports Israeli nationalism but is okay with White people being dispossessed in the West, it is understandable that they will get accused of being anti-Western
</blockquote>
me: So, JEW, you clearly understand why we White gentiles are angry. Why not just change your jewish anti White behavior, rather than pushing your hasbara jewish bs?
<blockquote>Not to mention that most of the White gentile elite are on board with policies, like mass immigration, and are quick to throw ordinary Whites under the bus.</blockquote>
me: Yeah, maybe because you jews dominate the msm, and the judenpresse and jewish ngos will literally destroy anyone that gets out of line with the jewish White genocide and jewish anti White agenda. Just look at what jewish terrorists did to kanye west, whoopie goldberg, rick sanchez, the president of harvard, and president of penn when they dared to get out of line. In addition, jews have been getting dirt on White gentiles for a long time in order to get them in line with the jewish anti White agenda. You know, the way epstein/mossad did to countless people! Jews love to terrorize non jews....and then they whine like little girls when non jews dare to fight back. It's your sick ethnocult that demands jews make non jews serve jewish interests. It's your sick ethnocult that demands jews terrorize non jews:
https://www.unz.com/article/fear-of-the-jews-and-the-jewish-god-of-terror/
<blockquote>
What the Alt-Right gets wrong is that Jewish people who supported BLM generally don’t care for Netanyahu, and </blockquote>
me: What YOU get wrong jew, is that we don't care. Jews, whether left wing, or right wing are against White gentiles pushing for our interests in our nations. Thus, jews are the enemies of White gentiles. Until YOU jews support White identity politics the way you support jewish/hispanic/black, etc identity politics in the west, all we will consider you is enemies. Capisce, shlomo?
<blockquote>The Alt-Right will use anti-racist activist, Tim Wise</blockquote>
me: jew tim wise isn't an "anti racist activist", he is just another jewish anti White scumball that grifts off of gullible non Whites and brain-dead White gentile lefttards. He's a complete hypocrite on race.
<blockquote>While George Soros is often given as an example of a Jewish oligarch who funds the Great Replacement, it is important to point out that Soros also funds anti-Israel causes.</blockquote>
me: So? When has soros funded open borders for israel? When has soros funded groups trying to prevent identity politics for jews in israel and abroad? When has soros tried to destroy the jewish ADL and other jewish ngos that are absolutely against quote-unquote "open societies" and free speech? I'll help you here. The answer is never!
At bare minimum it's fun to ridicule people who fail to live up to their own rhetoric.
Palestine and Palestinians have nothing to do with America First. Neither does Israel. If someone invokes Israel and its concerns they are trying to link Zionism with America First. George Washington said, "Anyone who believes two nations can have identical interests is delusional". Israel is our greatest liability, and apparently we will let it plummet us to the bottom of the sea with Bibi and Trump "in control".
Mitigation.
Thought provoking article - thank you Robert. When you use the enemy's verbiage, you legitimize their ideology. Say antiwhite. That's what they are, whether they call themselves "woke" or "anti-racist". What you called hypocrisy is just their consistent antiwhiteism, no?
very good writing, although I do not agree with all of it
The civilised world is becoming increasingly multicultural. Ethnonationalism will have no place in 2100, and Israel in its current form will have to accept multiculturalism and pluralism or become a Rightoid pariah state. No doubt Israel supporters will shift rightward as Israel goes in a similar direction, allowing more steam to be released by tactfully talking about "anti-whiteness" to get the Western rubes on board. In the long term, it's not going to work; the direction Israel is going in is towards religious fundamentalism, blood and soil nationalism, and ethnic cleansing. This can provide Western Rightoids a way to live vicariously through Israel as it commits these crimes—since they can't commit these actions against Muslims in the West—but it will also make them look like ghouls.